February 17, 2005
Practical Case Studies for Maintenance and Reliability Professionals

Vibration Monitoring Keeps Paper Production Rolling

Vibration analysis of a mission-critical secondary centri-cleaner pump on a paper machine revealed that the overall vibration trend, 1x turning speed and vane pass, had been quickly rising for several weeks. Production was alerted and tried adjusting the valves and controls, but was not able to correct the problem.

A broken or cracked shaft was suspected because of the 1x cpm amplitude changing. The high-end data showing a rise in the noise floor and the vane pass rising revealed that cavitation was also a problem. After putting all of the information together, the predictive maintenance team deducted that the pump shaft could have a plugged or restricted line.

On repair day, maintenance technicians removed the runner and found a lot of debris including a rusted bracket, several bolts and a piece of wood lodged in the impeller. The unit had been pumping with restricted ports on the suction side of the pump.


Wood Lodged in Pump Impeller

This repair was scheduled on a regular outage. Had the pump failed, paper production would have come to a halt and production loss cost alone would have exceeded $30,000.

The question that the team now faces is "Where did the debris come from and is there any more still upstream?"

Submitted by Charles "Sandy" White, Blue Ridge Paper.

Send Us Your Case Study
If we publish your story in Reliability Case Studies, we'll send you $250. To submit your case study, review the guidelines and send your case study to casestudies@noria.com.

 

Reliability Case Studies Newsletter is published biweekly by:
Noria Corporation, 1328 E. 43rd Court, Tulsa, OK 74105 USA. (918) 749-1400

Because results will vary widely based on a number of factors, Noria Corporation cannot warrant the results of any material within this e-mail.

© 2005 Noria Corporation

»Receive your own subscription to Reliability Case Studies


Other Resources:

»Archives
»Machinery Lubrication Magazine
»Practicing Oil Analysis Magazine
»Bookstore
»Buyers Guide
»Dictionary